Documentation, naming things. Hard. Let’s see this hardness compound at the intersection of these two phenomena in the real world.
I’m casually scanning the Apollo docs, reading up on subscriptions because my wife is writing graphql client code at work. (I had vague memories of how we worked with distributed event streaming at my last job. NestJS + Kafka. We had consolidated apis into a graphql layer, but worked with Kafka event streams through Nest with the kafka-js lib as a bridge. Point is, I wanted a light refreshment of how this stuff works.).
It’s a frustrating moment to jump between these two pieces of the documentation. (This is supposed to be a mature framework (sobbing, why can’t we have nice things)). From 2. Initialize a GraphQLWsLink to Enabling subscriptions.
The former section, which walks us through client setup, provides a callout with a detour into the server docs for grabbing the connection url we need for configuring and instantiating our web socket linkage.
Replace the value of the url option with your GraphQL server’s subscription-specific WebSocket endpoint. If you’re using Apollo Server, see Setting a subscription endpoint.
If we are using Apollo’s server, then we must pass a url property when creating and instantiating the GraphQLWsLink object .
const wsLink = new GraphQLWsLink(createClient({
url: 'ws://localhost:4000/subscriptions',
}));
HOWEVER, once we hyperlink to the server docs one simply cannot find – throughout the entire web document – a mention of “endpoint.” We’re dropped into a section called “Enabliing subscriptions” – instruction for setting up the server side bits.
Let down. Expectations missed. Problematic asymmetry, lack of consistency!
Repletely kerfuffled, my synapses delivering a reminiscence of Tom Benner’s big bird bound Naming Things, and his chapter on Consistency. (This so happens to be one of my favorite dogmas of Better Naming™️.) Well, the Apollo docs demonstrate a similar symptom of bad naming, just like the kinds of bad examples we oft find in code. Join me in considering disparate, hyperlinked documents as analogs to components of a software program that exchange messages. Readers of these texts suffer the bad naming with familiar symptoms: frustration. Capitalists lose the most with anemic productivity.
If the hyperlink is a documentation document-as-component api/interface, us readers should be allowed to charismatically move back and forth without being flung out from our flow state like starships intercepted in warp. Perhaps the doc could send me to a subsection of “Enabling Subscriptions” titled/anchored with “Server endpoint” (or the like). My instinct is that there’s a deeper scoop here.
Of course, there’s an imperfect system to blame. When Trevor Scheer removed all mention of “endpoint” in the docs update preparing users for Apollo Server version 3 back in 2021 – Apollo Server would no longer include inherent support for websocket protocols – how closely did he collaborate with Stephen Barlow who initially committed the instructions referencing endpoints a year or so before. Do the people matter? (They do.) And from under whatever constraints they perform these literary efforts. We can wonder, imagine, daydream about the socio-technical system that produces docs for clients and servers, and how the basic capabilities of the web link them together. The bounded contexts. The challenges of producing universal languages, ubiquitous terms across what likely are two disparate teams.
There are some leaky abstractions, but it’s not a total system failure.
I’m reading Bax.
Dispatches, bulletins, papers, pinned up, spewed about The Hospital Ship.
Page 15: A chronic shortage of pins to fix up the reports, so that in consequence they blrew away and anyone in the stern of the ship could reach out a hand and collect bulletins from the air as they drifted by in an endless paper-chase over the stern of the boat and on into the sea.
Page 98: Did the programmers hope to attract some reply? The Hopeful did not know what replay to make so they transmitted their call signal only, but there was no response.
Euan wants to blame Tafteria, too bad.